Sports Analytics Is Universal. But what about the payoffs?
↓
Want to go deeper? This is one of the concepts we explore in the People Analytics course, where we go from theory to actually applying these ideas to real workforce problems.
Back in September, the Revelio Labs team presented at our Toronto People Analytics meetup.
Last month they published a study I was very excited to read.
They looked at every team in MLB, the NBA, the NFL, the NHL and the UEFA Champions League. And asked one question:
Do data hires actually help teams win?
Sports should be the easy case. Every pitch, pass and shot gets recorded. The outcome is a number on a scoreboard. Nobody argues about whether the quarter was a "win."
If analytics pays off anywhere, it should pay off here.
Right?
The truthful answer: it depends.
And the reasons it depends are the same reasons your People Analytics team may not be delivering what you hoped for at the start.
Let me explain.
What the data says (Analytics on Analytics)
First, analytics in pro sports is now basically universal.
Every NBA and MLB team has at least one data professional. The NBA got there first, in 2015. The NFL took almost 15 years to catch up to the leaders. Even the Champions League, the laggard, is above 80%.
Then Revelio compared each team's win percentage in the three seasons before and after its first data hire.
Baseball and soccer teams saw win rates go up 5 to 7%
NBA teams saw win percentage go down
The top three teams in each sport (2023 to 2025) do not have a higher share of data staff than everyone else.
Wait, what?
I see four lessons in here. Each one maps straight onto HR.
Lesson 1: Don't take credit for the bounce
Baseball and soccer clubs tended to hire their first analyst after a slump.
Leagues that hired during good stretches saw no further boost.
If you read the issue a few weeks ago, this should ring a bell.
Regression to the mean.
A team that just had a terrible season is likely to have a better one next year. Not because of the analyst. Because terrible seasons contain a lot of bad luck, and bad luck doesn't repeat on schedule. Unless you are cursed.
To be fair to Revelio, they controlled for prior performance. That's the right move. But the pattern itself should make any analyst pause: how much of the improvement is the hire, and how much is the "bounce?"
Now think about when most People Analytics teams get funded.
After an attrition spike. After a bad engagement year. After the CEO asks a question nobody can answer.
So the team is born at the bottom of the curve. Twelve months later, attrition is down and engagement is up. And there is a slide that says "Impact of People Analytics."
Some of that is real. Some of it was coming anyway. If you can't tell which is which, neither can your CFO.
Lesson 2: An edge everyone has is not an edge
The NBA result is the most interesting one. And it has a simple explanation.
NBA teams adopted analytics at roughly the same time. When everyone gets the same edge, nobody has an edge.
Look at the three-point shot. The math said threes are worth more than long twos. A few teams figured that out early and won with it. Then everyone figured it out. League-wide, NBA teams went from about 22 three-point attempts per game a decade ago to 37.5 in 2024-25.
Taking a lot of threes no longer wins you games. It just keeps you from losing them.
Baseball has the same story. Moneyball made getting on base famous as an underpriced skill. Economists Jahn Hakes and Raymond Sauer later showed the player market did misprice certain skills in the early 2000s, then corrected once the knowledge spread. The Oakland A's edge had a shelf life. The book shortened it.
If you know me, you know I'll bring this back to markets.
In finance, this is called alpha decay. McLean and Pontiff studied 97 published stock-return predictors in the Journal of Finance. Returns were 26% lower out-of-sample, and 58% lower after the research was published. The moment an edge is written down, the market starts eating it.
Edges decay when they get published.
HR has published a lot.
Engagement benchmarks. Attrition risk models. Skills taxonomies. The same survey vendors, the same dashboards, the same conference talks. That is table stakes now. It keeps you from losing.
But... It does not make you win.
Lesson 3: Having analysts is not the same as using them
Here is where it gets interesting.
A 2025 MIT study by Henry Wang, Arnab Sarker and Anette Hosoi looked at all 30 NBA teams across 12 seasons. They controlled for payroll, roster experience, coaching, injuries and more. Teams with bigger analytics departments won more games. Their preferred model puts it at about 1.25 extra wins per analyst. With diminishing returns as departments grow.
So which is it? Do NBA analysts help or not?
Both studies can be right.
Revelio looked at the first hire.
MIT looked at the depth of the department.
One analyst is a badge. You can say you "do analytics." A department that is built into how the coaches, scouts and front office make decisions is a capability.
And then there's money. Revelio is upfront that they can't separate its effect. Rich teams hire analysts. Rich teams also win. Sound familiar? It's the same confounding problem we saw with retention and the labour market a few weeks ago.
So the honest reading is this. Analytics helps when it is deep enough to change decisions. It helps less with each extra hire. And a lot of what looks like an "analytics effect" is a budget effect.
Lesson 4: The biggest gains came where the game is hardest to measure
The Champions League showed the largest improvement after a first data hire. MLB was almost as large.
Those two sports could not be more different.
Baseball is a series of discrete events. Pitch, swing, result. Classic statistics work beautifully. And Revelio found baseball job postings ask for statistical analysis skills more than any other sport.
Soccer is continuous and messy. Twenty-two players, constant movement, very few goals. For years it was too hard to measure well. Now soccer clubs post the highest demand for AI, machine learning and data engineering skills.
And soccer has the lowest adoption of the five leagues. Fewer competitors with the capability means the edge is still there to take.
The lesson: the edge lives where measurement is hard and competitors are few.
Let's apply this to HR
Your People Analytics team is a data hire too.
And the HR.com research I wrote about in February shows the same pattern as the NBA. The share of organizations seeing value from people analytics fell from 57% in 2023 to 45% in 2025. Only 23% feel effective at designing the processes to get that value.
We all built the dashboards (or many of us do).
Few of us changed the decisions.
Here's how I would run the function differently.
Measure yourself the way Revelio measured teams. Before and after, with a comparison group. If you launched a retention program in two business units, compare them against the units you didn't touch, and against your industry's quit rate. Then report the difference. Not the raw change.
Assume your edge decays. Once a year, list every analysis you run that your competitors also run. That is parity. Then ask: what do we know about our people that nobody else knows? If the answer is "nothing," that's your roadmap.
Go where measurement is hard. Hiring, exits and headcount look like baseball. Easy to count, and everyone counts them. Manager quality, collaboration and team dynamics look like soccer. Messy, underexplored and full of edge. Staff for that game.
Build depth, not a badge. One analyst sitting outside the decision room is probably for show. Put your analysts inside the forums where workforce decisions get made: talent reviews, budget planning, the restructuring discussion. Then count how many decisions they changed this quarter.
Price the next hire on marginal value. Your second analyst is worth more than your sixth. Before you add headcount, name the decision the new person will improve and what that decision is worth.
Separate budget from skill. When you benchmark your function against other companies, control for size and spend. A bigger company with a bigger team will look "more mature." That's beta. You are looking for alpha.
Every team in the NBA has analysts.
Not every team in the NBA wins.
K
Whenever you’re ready, there are 2 ways I can help you:
#1
If you’re still looking to get started in People Analytics, I recommend starting with my affordable course:
Practical People Analytics: Build data-driven HR programs to 10x your professional effectiveness, business impact, and career. This comprehensive course will teach you everything from building an HR dashboard for business results to driving growth through more advanced analytics (i.e., regression). Join your peers today!
#2
If you are looking for support in your human capital programs, such as engagement, retention, and compensation & benefits, and want to take a more data-driven approach, contact me at Tskhay & Associates for consulting services. Or simply reply to this email!
by Konstantin Tskhay November 11th The Cost of Waiting: Why Gathering More Information Is Not Free ↓ Want to go deeper?This is one of the concepts we explore in the People Analytics course, where we go from theory to actually applying these ideas to real workforce problems. Learn more about the People Analytics course → Hi Friends, Leaders looove to wait for more data. Just look at the last 3-4 years of Jerome Powell and now Kevin Warsh speaking about waiting for more data before making...
by Konstantin Tskhay November 3rd The Theory of Constraints in People Analytics: Why the Bottleneck Never Disappears ↓ Hi Friends, This week, I spent some time thinking about my own business metrics and have stumbled at this new construct of Theory of Constraints. Here is the senario: You hit some KPIs, say some product or some HR KPI. You launch some programs. Perhaps some engagement initiatives or processes to improve recruitment. You hope this will improve your sales. But... Top-line...
by Konstantin Tskhay October 28th Was It Skill or Was It Luck? The Statistics Behind Exceptional Performance ↓ Want to go deeper?This is one of the concepts we explore in the People Analytics course, where we go from theory to actually applying these ideas to real workforce problems. Learn more about the People Analytics course → Hi Friends, Been a busy week here in Toronto. I spent a morning the other day thinking about how my client is looking at performance. And, in particular, measure...